LYFE Sciences · Project HERA
Variant Interpretation · Classification Report
Variant classification summary
NM_000157.4: c.1093G>A
GBA1
· NP_000148.2:p.(Glu365Lys)
· NM_000157.4
GRCh37: chr1:155206167 C>T
·
GRCh38: chr1:155236376 C>T
Gene:
GBA1
Transcript:
NM_000157.4
Final call
Benign
BS1 supporting
BS2 strong
BS4 strong
BP2 supporting
BP5 supporting
Variant details
Gene
GBA1
Transcript
NM_000157.4
Protein
NP_000148.2:p.(Glu365Lys)
gnomAD AF
0.012312185426852992 (v4.1)
ClinVar
Benign
OncoKB
Classification rationale
Interpretation summary
Generated evidence synthesis
1
BS2 (Strong): 196 gnomAD v4.1 homozygotes without Gaucher disease show biallelic carriage of this allele is non-pathogenic.
2
BS4 (Strong): in a Gaucher disease family, E326K did not segregate with disease - affected members lack it while unaffected carriers have it.
3
BS1 (Supporting): gnomAD v4.1 allele frequency 1.23% far exceeds the expected frequency for a Gaucher disease allele.
4
BP2 (Supporting): E326K occurs in cis with pathogenic L444P/N188S and is never found alone on a disease-causing allele.
5
BP5 (Supporting): affected family members carrying E326K have a documented alternate molecular basis (trans G202R or L444P).
6
Overall Benign: two strong benign criteria (BS2 + BS4) satisfy the Benign combination rule, with additional supporting BS1, BP2, and BP5.
Final determination:
Generic ACMG/AMP 2015 fallback combination rule (PMID:25741868): two strong benign criteria (BS2 strong, BS4 strong) are met, and the rule '(2 BS) -> Benign' yields Benign; the additional supporting benign criteria (BS1, BP2, BP5) are consistent, and no pathogenic criterion is met, so no conflicting-evidence override applies.
Criteria assessment
ACMG/AMP criteria review
Criteria shown when status is available
All criteria require review: For research and educational purposes only.
| Criterion | Status | Rationale | Evidence used |
|---|---|---|---|
| PVS1 | N/A | Not applicable: this is a missense substitution, so none of the null-variant mechanisms PVS1 requires (nonsense-mediated decay, truncation, canonical splice disruption) are triggered. |
pvs1_generic_framework
generic_acmg_combination_rules
|
| PS1 | Not met | Not met: p.Glu365Lys (E326K) is documented as a non-pathogenic polymorphic allele, so no established-pathogenic same-amino-acid comparator exists. |
PMID:12791040
PMID:15146461
PMID:16293621
PMID:25741868
|
| PS2 | Not met | Not met: no de novo occurrence is documented; gnomAD v4.1 shows a 1.23% allele frequency with 196 homozygotes, and family data show paternal inheritance. |
PMID:12791040
clinvar
gnomad_v4
gnomad_v2
|
| PS3 | Not met | Not met: functional studies show 43-55% residual glucocerebrosidase activity, far above the near-complete loss (<15%) seen in pathogenic GBA1 alleles. |
PMID:15146461
PMID:16293621
PMID:26117366
PMID:12791040
|
| PS4 | Not met | Not met: E326K showed no significant case-control enrichment (13/517 cases vs 3/252 controls, P=0.289). Flagged for human review: larger published E326K/PD association studies were not available for evaluation. |
PMID:26117366
PMID:12791040
|
| PM1 | Not met | Not met: Glu365 is a surface residue outside the active site, and the site carries abundant benign variation (gnomAD v4.1 AF 1.23%), failing the 'without benign variation' condition. |
PMID:16293621
PMID:12791040
gnomad_v4
PMID:25741868
|
| PM2 | Not met | Not met: gnomAD v4.1 allele frequency 1.23% is orders of magnitude above the <0.1% extremely-low-frequency threshold. |
gnomad_v4
gnomad_v2
gnomad_canada
PMID:25741868
|
| PM3 | Not met | Not met: carriers with this allele in trans with pathogenic G202R or L444P are phenotypically normal, refuting a recessive pathogenic role. |
PMID:12791040
PMID:15146461
PMID:26117366
gnomad_v2
gnomad_v4
|
| PM4 | N/A | Not applicable: this is a missense substitution, so no protein-length change occurs for this criterion to evaluate. |
pvs1_generic_framework
generic_acmg_combination_rules
|
| PM5 | Not met | Not met: no different missense change at residue Glu365 has been established as pathogenic; the only characterized change there, p.Glu365Lys, is a common polymorphism. |
pm5_candidates
PMID:12791040
PMID:15146461
PMID:25741868
|
| PM6 | Not met | Not met: no assumed de novo occurrence is documented, and a 1.23%-frequency polymorphism with 196 homozygotes is implausible as a de novo event. |
PMID:12791040
clinvar
gnomad_v4
gnomad_v2
|
| PP1 | Not met | Not met: segregation data affirmatively contradict co-segregation - the affected proband lacks E326K while unaffected relatives carry it. |
PMID:12791040
clinvar
|
| PP2 | Not met | Not met: GBA1 has a high rate of benign missense variation - p.Glu365Lys itself is a 1.23%-frequency polymorphism (196 gnomAD v4.1 homozygotes). |
PMID:12791040
PMID:15146461
PMID:16293621
gnomad_v4
PMID:25741868
|
| PP3 | Not met | Not met: SpliceAI max delta 0.00 predicts no splice impact, and REVEL 0.595 falls below the 0.773 supporting threshold, so no calibrated computational support exists. |
spliceai
revel
bayesdel
clinvar
cspec
PMID:25741868
|
| PP4 | Not met | Not met: the phenotype is not highly specific to a single genetic etiology - this allele is a low-penetrance Parkinson's risk factor, not a Gaucher disease-causing variant. |
PMID:12791040
PMID:15146461
PMID:26117366
gnomad_v2
|
| PP5 | Not met | Not met: ClinVar record VCV000199044 has zero expert-panel submissions, and only laboratory assertions exist, which cannot trigger PP5. |
clinvar
|
| BA1 | Not met | Not met: gnomAD v4.1 allele frequency 1.23% is below the >5% stand-alone benign threshold, and the allele is a documented low-penetrance Parkinson's risk factor. |
gnomad_v4
gnomad_v2
PMID:25741868
PMID:26117366
PMID:15146461
cspec
|
| BS1 | Met | Met (supporting): gnomAD v4.1 allele frequency 1.23% is 2.5-4x above the >0.3% convention and far exceeds the expected frequency for a Gaucher disease allele. |
gnomad_v4
gnomad_v2
gnomad_canada
PMID:25741868
PMID:12791040
PMID:26117366
cspec
|
| BS2 | Met | Met (strong): 196 homozygotes in gnomAD v4.1 (and 37 in v2.1) are biallelic without Gaucher disease, indicating this allele does not cause the recessive disorder. |
gnomad_v4
gnomad_v2
gnomad_canada
PMID:12791040
PMID:16293621
PMID:15146461
PMID:25741868
cspec
|
| BS3 | Not met | Not met: the ~40-55% residual enzyme activity is a partial functional deficit, so the studies do not establish that E326K has no damaging effect. Flagged for human review: the partial loss is mechanistically relevant to Parkinson's risk even though it argues against Gaucher pathogenicity. |
PMID:15146461
PMID:16293621
PMID:26117366
PMID:12791040
|
| BS4 | Met | Met (strong): in a Gaucher disease family, affected members lack E326K while unaffected relatives carry it (G202R/E326K, L444P/E326K), demonstrating lack of segregation with disease. |
PMID:12791040
clinvar
|
| BP1 | N/A | Not applicable: Gaucher disease and GBA1-related parkinsonism are caused predominantly by missense variants, so the truncating-variant premise of BP1 does not hold. |
PMID:15146461
PMID:16293621
PMID:25741868
|
| BP2 | Met | Met (supporting): E326K is observed in cis with pathogenic L444P or N188S on complex Gaucher alleles, and never alone on a disease-causing allele. |
PMID:15146461
PMID:12791040
|
| BP3 | N/A | Not applicable: this is a missense substitution, not an in-frame indel in a repetitive region, so BP3 does not apply. |
pvs1_generic_framework
generic_acmg_combination_rules
|
| BP4 | Not met | Not met: only one calibrated computational line exists (SpliceAI max delta 0.00); REVEL 0.595 is uninformative and in silico predictions disagree, failing the multiple-lines requirement. |
spliceai
revel
bayesdel
clinvar
cspec
PMID:25741868
|
| BP5 | Met | Met (supporting): affected family members carry E326K alongside a documented alternate molecular basis - pathogenic G202R or L444P in trans. |
PMID:12791040
|
| BP6 | Not met | Not met: no ClinVar expert-panel benign classification exists for VCV000199044; only single-submitter laboratory assertions are present. |
clinvar
|
| BP7 | N/A | Not applicable: this is a missense substitution, not a synonymous variant, so the BP7 silent-variant premise does not hold. |
generic_acmg_combination_rules
|
Disclaimer:
The content and results provided by LYFE Sciences are for research and educational purposes only and must not be used as a substitute for professional medical judgment, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional before making any clinical decisions.