The BRCA2 c.4757C>T (p.Thr1586Ile) variant has been reported in ClinVar as likely benign by one clinical laboratory.1 This variant is absent from gnomAD v2.1 and gnomAD-Canada and is present only once in gnomAD v4.1 (1/1,613,958 alleles; AF 6.20e-07), which is far below ENIGMA benign frequency thresholds but does not meet the requirement for complete absence from controls.2 No variant-specific functional assay result for p.(Thr1586Ile) was identified in the reviewed BRCA2 ENIGMA functional resources.3 Computational evidence does not support a damaging effect: p.(Thr1586Ile) lies outside the BRCA2 clinically important domains used for ENIGMA missense interpretation, SpliceAI shows a maximum delta score of 0.01, BayesDel no-AF is -0.443818, and REVEL is 0.182, supporting BP1_Strong and not supporting PP3.4