Reasoning
PS3 is met at Strong. The exact synonymous variant NM_000218.3:c.1032G>A (p.(Ala344=)) has multiple independent, variant-specific functional studies showing a damaging effect through aberrant splicing and loss of KCNQ1 function. PMID:17292394 studied three unrelated long-QT-syndrome families and found increased exon-skipping transcripts in affected individuals versus controls; the resulting Delta7 and Delta8 products produced no measurable current and significantly reduced current when co-expressed with wild-type KCNQ1, with abnormal intracellular localization. PMID:21810471 confirmed the splice defect using patient RNA and minigene assays, quantified the abnormal transcript pattern, and reported Xenopus oocyte currents of 41.4+/-9.5% of control with KCNE1 co-expression. PMID:29857160 used patient-derived hiPSC-cardiomyocytes and found full-length KCNQ1 transcripts reduced to 42.16% versus 91.94% in controls, multiple aberrant splice products, and abnormal electrophysiology including prolonged field-potential/action-potential measures and EAD-like waveforms. PMID:10477533 independently reported loss of exons 6 and 7 in mutant transcripts from affected-family lymphoblastoid cells. These are approved VCEP functional categories, directly assess splicing and channel function, include control comparisons, and are concordant rather than conflicting. The VCEP rule identifies well-established functional studies supportive of a damaging effect as applicable at Strong; the available evidence is stronger than a single preliminary observation and includes patient-derived material, orthogonal assay systems, and reproducible abnormal molecular/electrophysiologic results.
VCEP rule
Well-established _in vitro_ or _in vivo_ functional studies supportive of a damaging effect on the gene or gene product. Note: Functional studies that have been validated and shown to be reproducible and robust in a clinical diagnostic laboratory setting are considered the most well-established.
Evidence considered
- VCEP KCNQ1 pilot-results row for NM_000218.3(KCNQ1):c.1032G>A (p.Ala344=), ClinVar ID 3135: PS3 applied; total points 10; VCEP classification Pathogenic.
- Tsuji et al. 2007, PMID:17292394: three unrelated LQTS families; affected transcripts had Delta7 23.5%, Delta7-8 16.8%, and Delta8 4.5% versus controls 0.0%, 0.1%, and 6.9%; aberrant products produced no measurable current alone, while Delta7 and Delta8 significantly reduced current with wild-type KCNQ1.
- Tsuji-Wakisaka et al. 2011, PMID:21810471: patient lymphocyte RNA and minigene assays showed exon-skipping transcripts; modeled transcript ratios produced 41.4+/-9.5% of control potassium current in Xenopus oocytes with KCNE1.
- Itoh et al. 2018, PMID:29857160: patient-derived hiPSC-cardiomyocytes showed full-length KCNQ1 transcripts at 42.16% versus 91.94% in controls, seven aberrant RNA variants, prolonged electrophysiologic measures, and EAD-like waveforms.
- Murray et al. 1999, PMID:10477533: affected-family lymphoblastoid-cell RT-PCR showed loss of exons 6 and 7 in c.1032G>A transcripts, supporting a splice-altering effect.
Sources