Reasoning
PS3 is met at supporting strength. PMID:10351951 directly studied the exact CFTR variant, historically reported as 3849 + 10 kb C→T, in fetal tissues using semiquantitative nondifferential and differential RT-PCR. The assay demonstrated insertion of an 84-bp cryptic exon containing an in-frame stop codon and markedly reduced correctly spliced CFTR RNA, with normal transcript proportions of 26% in lung, 17% in trachea, 19% in colon, 2% in pancreas, and 1% in ileum. The concordant aberrant splicing and organ pathology support a damaging effect on CFTR RNA processing. Supporting rather than stronger functional evidence is assigned because this is a single fetal-tissue study, not an independently replicated, clinically validated diagnostic assay, and the available extract does not establish a full control/replication framework.
Rule
Well-established in vitro or in vivo functional studies supportive of a damaging effect on the gene or gene product.
Evidence considered
- Chiba-Falek et al. 1999, PMID:10351951, Results and Discussion/Table 1: the exact variant 3849 + 10 kb C→T (NM_000492.4:c.3718-2477C>T) created a partially active splice site and inserted an 84-bp cryptic exon containing an in-frame stop codon.
- Chiba-Falek et al. 1999, PMID:10351951, semiquantitative nondifferential and differential RT-PCR of fetal organs: correctly spliced CFTR mRNA represented 26% in lung, 17% in trachea, 19% in colon, 2% in pancreas, and 1% in ileum; ileum had severe meconium ileus and histopathologic abnormalities.
Still missing
- Independent replication in additional samples or laboratories is not documented.
- The available evidence does not establish validation in a clinical diagnostic laboratory with fully described assay controls.
Sources