Reasoning
The KCNQ1 VCEP requires the variant not to meet BS1 and requires affected probands with QTc >=460 ms; supporting PS4 requires 2 independent observations, moderate requires 3-5 probands, and strong requires 6 or more probands. The literature packet lists multiple PS4 candidates, but it provides no verified affected-patient counts, QTc values, author-overlap resolution, or case-control table for this variant. PMID:12690509 was verified and reports screening 165 bodies found in water, with no KCNQ1-Fin:Gly589Asp carriers; this is not an affected-patient case series and supplies no case-control enrichment estimate. PMID:15140888 was verified as a functional trafficking/electrophysiology study, not a clinical case-control study. gnomAD v3.1 non-cancer reports 8/147930 alleles overall and 8/10622 Finnish alleles, but no matched affected-case count is available, so an OR and 95% CI cannot be computed. PS4 cannot be evaluated from the available evidence.
VCEP rule
The prevalence of the variant in affected individuals is significantly increased compared to the prevalence in controls
Evidence considered
- VCEP PS4 rule: supporting requires 2 independent observations, moderate requires 3-5 probands, strong requires 6 or more probands, and affected patients must have QTc measurement greater than or equal to 460ms.
- PMID:12690509, Results and discussion/Figure 1: KCNQ1-Fin:Gly589Asp was screened in 165 consecutive bodies found in water; no KCNQ1-Fin:Gly589Asp carriers were identified.
- PMID:15140888, Results, 'Mistrafficking of Reported LQT1 Mutants in This Region,' Fig. 8A-B: G589D was evaluated functionally; the paper does not provide an affected-patient case-control comparison.
- gnomAD v3.1 non-cancer: 8/147930 alleles overall and 8/10622 Finnish alleles; without an affected-case count, no OR or 95% CI can be calculated.
Still missing
- Verify the PS4-indexed papers against abstracts or full text and extract independent affected proband counts, QTc values, author overlap, and any unaffected/population control counts.
- Obtain a matched case-control comparison or sufficient case and control counts to calculate the OR and 95% CI.
- Confirm whether the variant meets BS1 under the VCEP before applying PS4.
Sources