Reasoning
PS3 is met at strong strength. The exact HFE C282Y variant was tested in independent, biologically relevant functional systems with wild-type and comparator controls. In HEK293 cells, C282Y abolished beta-2-microglobulin interaction, eliminated detectable cell-surface expression, and caused intracellular/perinuclear retention, directly demonstrating defective HFE processing and trafficking (PMID:9162021). In a separate stable human neuroblastoma-cell system, C282Y altered HFE localization, ganglioside composition, sphingolipid-related gene expression, sphingosine-1-phosphate synthesis, morphology, and growth relative to wild-type HFE (PMID:21243428). A mouse model carrying the homologous C282Y substitution also showed abnormal HFE-dependent immune tolerance and cytotoxic T-cell responses (PMID:22531912). The concordant molecular, cellular, and in vivo findings support a damaging effect on the HFE gene product; the evidence is strong, although the studies were research assays rather than validated clinical diagnostic laboratory assays.
Rule
Well-established in vitro or in vivo functional studies supportive of a damaging effect on the gene or gene product. Note: Functional studies that have been validated and shown to be reproducible and robust in a clinical diagnostic laboratory setting are considered the most well-established.
Evidence considered
- PMID:9162021, Results and Discussion, Figures 1–3: stable HEK293 cells expressing wild-type, C282Y-mutant, or H63D-mutant HLA-H; C282Y completely abrogated beta-2-microglobulin interaction, prevented detectable cell-surface expression, and disrupted intracellular protein trafficking.
- PMID:21243428, Abstract and Results, Table 1 and Figures 2–7: stable SH-SY5Y cells expressing FLAG-tagged wild-type HFE, C282Y-HFE, or H63D-HFE showed altered localization, ganglioside composition, sphingolipid-gene expression, sphingosine-1-phosphate synthesis, morphology, and growth; five genes increased by >2-fold and two decreased relative to wild type.
- PMID:22531912, Results and Discussion, pp. 853–858: mice carrying the homologous mHfe-C282→Y substitution showed abnormal selection and differentiation of mHFE-reactive CD8+ T cells and rejection of mHFE-expressing skin grafts.
- The studies used wild-type HFE controls and, where reported, H63D comparator controls; the findings are concordant across direct protein trafficking, cellular phenotype, and an in vivo mouse model.
Sources