Reasoning
The VCEP requires Jarvik and Browning meiosis thresholds: for a single family, supporting evidence requires at least 3 meioses, moderate at least 4 meioses, and strong at least 5 meioses; for more than one family, the corresponding thresholds are 2, 3, and 4 meioses. PMID:11315828 states that segregation for HK54 was inconclusive because none of the diabetic or nondiabetic relatives who presented for screening carried R203H, but it does not provide a count of informative meioses or sufficient family genotypes for threshold calculation. Therefore PP1 cannot be assessed.
VCEP rule
Use thresholds suggested by Jarvik and Browning[<sup>7</sup>](#pmid_27236918) ... Use thresholds suggested by Jarvik and Browning[<sup>7</sup>](#pmid_27236918) ... Use thresholds suggested by Jarvik and Browning[<sup>7</sup>](#pmid_27236918)
Evidence considered
- HNF1A VCEP PP1 rule: single-family thresholds are supporting at 3 meioses, moderate at 4 meioses, and strong at 5 meioses; thresholds for more than one family are 2, 3, and 4 meioses, respectively.
- PMID:11315828, family cosegregation study: HK54 with HNF-1a R203H was described as having inconclusive segregation because none of the diabetic or nondiabetic screened relatives carried the mutation; no informative meiosis count is given.
Still missing
- The number of informative meioses and complete genotype-phenotype data for the HK54 family are not reported.
- No additional variant-specific family segregation dataset with countable meioses was identified.
Sources