Reasoning
PS3 is met at strong strength. Groeneweg et al. directly evaluated the exact PKP2 c.2146-1G>C splice-acceptor variant in RNA from a variant carrier using RT-PCR, agarose-gel sizing, and Sanger sequencing, with a normal control and confirmation of approximately 1:1 wild-type and mutant transcripts. The mutant transcript showed exon 11 skipping (r.2146_2299del; p.(Met716fs)), producing a frameshift. The assay was biologically relevant to the canonical splice-site variant and included experimental confirmation rather than prediction alone. The study notes that blood-derived RNA may not fully represent cardiac splicing and that in vitro testing alone is not definitive, but the direct, variant-specific, reproducible molecular result is strongly supportive of a damaging effect on PKP2 splicing.
Rule
Well-established in vitro or in vivo functional studies supportive of a damaging effect on the gene or gene product.
Evidence considered
- Groeneweg et al. 2014, Results—PKP2 variants: exact c.2146-1G>C variant analyzed in a carrier's RNA by RT-PCR and Sanger sequencing; exon 11 was excluded and the resulting transcript was frameshifted.
- Groeneweg et al. 2014, Figure 2: normal control produced the expected 288-bp product, while the patient had an additional 153-bp product lacking exon 11; sequencing showed exon 10-to-exon 12 transition in the mutant allele.
- Groeneweg et al. 2014, Table 2: PKP2 c.2146-1G>C corresponded to r.2146_2299del and p.(Met716fs), with functional effect recorded as skipping of exon 11 and outcome recorded as pathogenic.
- The study explicitly reports that the patient sample contained approximately 1:1 wild-type and mutant PKP2 RT-PCR products, supporting biallelic assay interpretation, while acknowledging that peripheral-blood splicing may not fully reflect cardiac tissue.
Still missing
- The assay used peripheral-blood RNA rather than patient-derived cardiac tissue.
- Independent replication in an additional laboratory or cardiac model was not identified.
Sources