Reasoning
The VCEP requires phenotype points under Table 2A, only when PM2 is met, with PS4_Supporting requiring 0.5–1.25 points. PM2 is supported because the variant is absent from gnomAD v2.1 and v4.1. The available variant-specific literature reports C420R in tumor or experimental brain-tumor contexts, but does not provide a human affected-versus-unaffected case-control comparison or a count of patients with the VCEP-defined brain-malformation phenotypes. COSMIC reports 261 somatic occurrences, but the available record does not establish the number of distinct eligible primary tumors or exclude normal-tissue records; therefore only one verified tumor-presence category can be conservatively assigned (0.25 points), and the required comparison is 0.25 < 0.5, so PS4_Supporting is not met. The VCEP source text was searched for c.1258T>C, p.Cys420Arg, and p.C420R, with no variant-specific entry found in the governing full-text file.
VCEP rule
Points are assigned for phenotype according to (Table 2A). Phenotype criteria can only be used if the variant meets criteria for (PM2). Strength of evidence is determined by points according to (Table 2B). PS4_Supporting = 0.5 – 1.25 points.
Evidence considered
- ClinGen Brain Malformations VCEP Table 2A: presence of the variant in a tumor sample scores 0.25 points; the source also limits tumor counting and requires avoiding normal-tissue records.
- ClinGen Brain Malformations VCEP Table 2B: PS4_Supporting is 0.5–1.25 points; explicit comparison: 0.25 < 0.5, therefore the supporting threshold is not reached.
- The case population data report the variant absent from gnomAD v2.1 and gnomAD v4.1, satisfying the PS4 prerequisite that PM2 be met.
- COSMIC record COSV55874020 reports 261 somatic occurrences, but the available record does not establish eligible distinct primary tumors for conservative PS4 point assignment.
- PMID:21266528, cohort of 108 primary endometrial tumors: C420R is listed among exon 1–7 mutations, but the paper does not provide a C420R-specific affected-versus-control comparison.
- PMID:31996845, mouse glioblastoma and related experimental models: C420R drove tumorigenesis and brain-tumor phenotypes, but this is not a human case-control prevalence comparison for the VCEP phenotype.
Still missing
- No c.1258T>C, p.Cys420Arg, or p.C420R entry was found in clingen_brainmalform_acmg_specifications_v1_1.pdf.txt.
- No eligible human case-control counts or VCEP-defined brain-malformation phenotype counts were available for C420R.
- The COSMIC total of 261 does not identify distinct eligible primary tumors or exclude normal-tissue records, so additional tumor occurrences were not counted.
Sources