Reasoning
No variant-specific functional assay publication, assay result, control set, validation metrics, or animal-model result was identified in the case evidence. The governing VCEP specification requires PS3 functional assays to meet the acceptability criteria in PMID:31892348 and the BMVCEP Supplementary Document 1; the specification states that any publication in the spreadsheet may support PS3, while evidence above Supporting requires independent pathogenic/likely pathogenic positive controls and benign/likely benign negative controls. Because no assay evidence was available for NM_006218.4:c.562+14T>G / p.? and the governing file contains no entry for this variant, PS3 cannot be assessed at any strength.
VCEP rule
Award PS3 if the functional assay meets the acceptability criteria delimited in (PMID: 31892348) with specifications added by the BMVCEP. Quality metrics and minimum validation controls required can be found in Supplementary Document 1. ... Any publication within the spreadsheet can be used as evidence for a supporting level of evidence (PS3). ... Any paper must have validation controls (positive and negative) in order to be used as evidence for a level above supporting.
Evidence considered
- ClinGen Brain Malformations VCEP specification, Supplemental Document 1 (PS3): no variant-specific publication or assay result for NM_006218.4:c.562+14T>G / p.? was available in the case evidence.
- ClinGen Brain Malformations VCEP specification, Supplemental Document 1 (PS3): above-Supporting evidence requires positive controls classified as pathogenic/likely pathogenic independently of PS3 and negative controls classified as benign/likely benign independently of BS3; neither control set was available for this variant.
Still missing
- No entry for c.562+14T>G or p.? was found in clingen_brainmalform_acmg_specifications_v1_1.pdf.txt.
- Variant-specific functional assay data, assay controls, replicate information, and quality metrics are unavailable in the case evidence.
Sources