Reasoning
The VCEP permits PS4 for unrelated probands contributing phenotype points, with Supporting at 1–1.5 points, Moderate at 2–3.5 points, and Strong at ≥4 points. No case-level phenotype-point data for this exact variant are available. The four papers in the literature packet were checked through their extracted full-text findings: none mentions NM_177438.3:c.2367_2369delinsCTGATATCCTCCT or p.(R789Sfs*2), and none provides a case-control comparison for this variant. Therefore, no phenotype points, odds ratio, confidence interval, or qualifying rare-variant case series can be established.
VCEP rule
Unrelated probands may contribute up to 1 point each based on phenotype (see Tables 2 & 3 in ruleset) ... ≥4 phenotype points ... 2 – 3.5 phenotype points ... 1 – 1.5 phenotype points
Evidence considered
- ClinGen DICER1 VCEP PS4 rule: unrelated probands may contribute up to 1 point each based on phenotype; the PS4 strength thresholds are Supporting 1–1.5 phenotype points, Moderate 2–3.5 phenotype points, and Strong ≥4 phenotype points.
- PMID:20305640 full-text extraction: conditional mouse Dicer1 deletion study; the exact queried human variant was not mentioned, so it supplies no variant-specific phenotype or case-control evidence.
- PMID:21266384 full-text extraction: constitutional DICER1 mutation cohort of 823 individuals with various tumors; the exact queried variant was not reported, and no variant-specific affected-versus-control comparison was provided.
- PMID:21501861 full-text extraction: germline DICER1 mutations in patients with ovarian sex cord-stromal tumors; the exact queried variant was not mentioned, and no variant-specific control comparison was provided.
- PMID:22353998 full-text extraction: conditional mouse Dicer1 deletion study; the exact queried human variant was not mentioned, so it supplies no variant-specific phenotype or case-control evidence.
- No case-control odds ratio or 95% confidence interval was computed because no exact-variant case and control counts or matched-ancestry control frequency were available.
Still missing
- Variant-specific affected-proband phenotype data sufficient to assign VCEP phenotype points are unavailable.
- Variant-specific unaffected/control counts or matched-ancestry control frequency needed for a case-control comparison are unavailable.
Sources