Reasoning
The TP53 VCEP PS4 rule assigns points for Revised Chompret criteria (0.5), Classic LFS criteria (1), or HER2-positive breast cancer diagnosed before age 40 (0.5), with Supporting at 1-1.5 points, Moderate at 2-3.5, Strong at 4-7.5, and Very Strong at >=8. The PS4-Points-Table.pdf full text was searched for c.63C>T, p.Asp21=, and p.D21=; no variant-specific row was present. PMID:32000721 reports c.63C>T in 2 of 30 breast-cancer patients and 1 of 30 healthy female controls. Treating this as a case-control comparison, the uncorrected odds ratio is (2 x 29)/(28 x 1) = 2.07 with a Woolf 95% CI of 0.18-24.15; this does not establish the VCEP's required LFS point category, and the paper does not report the patients' ages, HER2 status, Revised Chompret status, or Classic LFS status. PMID:20436704 reports rs1800369C>T [D21D] as a germline polymorphism with MAF 0.392 in a Korean NSCLC cohort, but supplies no VCEP PS4 point-qualifying phenotype. Therefore PS4 cannot be assigned from the available evidence.
VCEP rule
PS4 points: Revised Chompret 0.5, Classic LFS criteria 1, or HER2+ breast cancer below age 40 0.5; PS4_Supporting = 1-1.5 points, PS4_Moderate = 2-3.5 points, PS4 = 4-7.5 points, PS4_Very Strong = >=8 points.
Evidence considered
- PS4-Points-Table.pdf, page 1: Revised Chompret = 0.5 point, Classic LFS criteria = 1 point, HER2-positive breast cancer under age 40 = 0.5 point; PS4_Supporting = 1-1.5 points, PS4_Moderate = 2-3.5 points, PS4 = 4-7.5 points, and PS4_Very Strong = >=8 points.
- PMID:32000721, Results/Table 3: TP53 c.63C>T (p.Asp21Asp) appeared in 2 breast-cancer patients and 1 healthy female control. The computed case-control odds ratio was 2.07, with Woolf 95% CI 0.18-24.15.
- PMID:20436704, Results paragraph 1: rs1800369C>T [D21D], corresponding to c.63C>T/p.(D21=), was reported as a germline polymorphism with MAF 0.392 in a cohort of 176 Korean NSCLC patients; no PS4 point-qualifying phenotype was given.
Still missing
- PS4-Points-Table.pdf was searched for c.63C>T, p.Asp21=, and p.D21=; no entry for this variant was found.
- The available case report lacks patient ages, HER2 status, Revised Chompret classification, and Classic LFS classification needed to assign PS4 points.
Sources